Judgment No. 1507
THE APPLICATION IS DISMISSED.
"According to consistent precedent the Tribunal will allow an application for review only in exceptional cases. Its judgments are, as Article VI of its Statute says, 'final and without appeal' and carry the authority of res judicata. Admissible grounds for review are strictly limited: failure to take account of a material fact, an error of fact which involves no exercise of judgment, failure to rule on a claim, and the discovery of a new fact which the complainant was unable to rely on in the original proceedings. Moreover, the plea must be such as to affect the original ruling: see Judgment 1255 [...] under 2." Inadmissible pleas for review are a mistake of law, failure to admit evidence, a wrong appraisal of the facts and failure to rule on pleas: see, for example, Judgment 442 [...], also under 2."
ILOAT reference: ARTICLE VI OF THE STATUTE
Jugement(s) TAOIT: 442, 1255
application for review; admissible grounds for review; finality of judgment; inadmissible grounds for review; res judicata; appraisal of evidence; iloat statute; mistake of law