Unit 2: Gender issues in the world of work
Emerging gender issues in the Asia Pacific region
Poverty
Gender and Poverty in Papua New Guinea
Gender and Poverty in Papua New Guinea
[Excerpt from Papua New Guinea Country Report, prepared by the Government of Papua New Guinea for the United Nations Fourth World Conference on Women, Beijing, China September 4-15, 1995]
Traditionally Papua New Guineans have been self-sufficient with highly developed agricultural and economic exchange systems. Today, poverty in rural areas of Papua New Guinea is not poverty in absolute terms of starvation and lack of shelter. Villagers have a base of subsistence farming and traditional shelter practices. This is not to deny that there are a few areas where there is agricultural stress and of shortages of land resulting in poor yields. Poverty must be viewed in terms of improvement on the basic traditional diet and nutrition and the standard of living.
Rural poverty is increasingly a function of lack of essential infrastructure and social services such as health and education, especially in the very remote rural areas. Where the infrastructure and social services are not available or are inadequate, there is often malnutrition and poor health. Those who are not part of the cash economy have low or virtually no income to supplement the traditional goods/food basket and have little chance of improvement in housing and general standard of living.
There are great improvements in the standard of living in some provinces such as East New Britain but this improvement is lagging in many other areas. It is not implied that poverty will not get worse in the rural country. What is required is more productive investment in the rural sector to stimulate income and employment generation development activities. These investments, making the rural sector more attractive, will help to minimize rural-urban migration.
In the urban areas, particularly Port Moresby and Lae, attaining nutritional and shelter requirements in dependent on employment. This dependence on the cash economy coupled with a lack of employment, has contributed to increasing urban poverty.
The 1994 United Nations Development Program Human Development Report placed Papua New Guinea low in ranking among 173 countries, based on classifications of education, life expectancy and the gross national product. These indicators, while important, do not adequately describe the situation of women and poverty in Papua New Guinea. To understand trends for the coming decade, nutrition, shelter, land and environment must also be considered.
The majority of people in Papua New Guinea are able to meet their basic nutritional needs and there is no real starvation in rural areas apart from localized food shortages due to natural disasters and a few pockets of severe malnutrition.... Women, particularly in rural areas, may be disadvantaged in terms of access to knowledge of food preparations of nutritional value. Women who are especially vulnerable to malnutrition are located in areas such as smallholder cash crop projects, plantations, urban squatter settlements and areas of high outmigration of able-bodied population.
The combined efforts on nutrition of various government departments such as Agriculture, Health and Education, along with women’s organizations and other nongovernment organizations, have resulted in the revision of the 1978 Food and Nutrition Policy with the adoption of the Papua New Guinea National Nutritional Policy which was endorsed by the national Executive Council in March 1995. The National Plan of Action for nutrition is being finalised for endorsement by the Government in the November 1995 session. As a complement to the National Nutritional Policy, the Department of agriculture and Livestock is drafting a National Food Crops and Livestock Policy. The overall policy objectives are contained in the White Paper on Agricultural Policies which will be endorsed by the National Executive Council in the November 1995 Budget Session. The recent initiative by government on the Child Survival Cash Program has brought to light many of these nutritional concerns and has seen commitments from non-governmental organizations and agencies concerned with improving the welfare of mothers and children.
Women are having to take more responsibility for supporting the family, often the extended family. There has been an increase in the percentage of female-headed households over the last 15 years. Census figures on head of household by sex in 1980 show that a total of 641,605 households, 81,857 or 12.7% were females. Of this number, 4% were involved in money-raising activities and the remaining 8.7% were involved in other, largely subsistence, activities. By 1990, female headed households had increased to 15%. Of this group, 27.7% supported 8 or more family members. Table 3 shows the relative differences between rural and urban households in 1990.
TABLE 3: Percent Distribution of Citizen Households by Size, by Sex, of Household Heads,
|
Household |
Rural |
Urban |
||
|
Size |
Male |
Female |
Male |
Female |
|
All Types |
490,882 |
74,244 |
70,417 |
10,038 |
|
1 person |
3.5 |
8.1 |
5.8 |
4.5 |
|
2 person |
8.4 |
14.5 |
5.9 |
8.2 |
|
3 person |
12.9 |
16.6 |
8.2 |
9.9 |
|
4 person |
14.4 |
16.5 |
10.7 |
12.0 |
|
5 person |
14.9 |
14.2 |
11.9 |
12.6 |
|
6 person |
14.1 |
10.8 |
12.3 |
12.4 |
|
7 person |
15.1 |
9.6 |
13.6 |
12.6 |
|
8 & more |
16.6 |
9.5 |
31.6 |
27.7 |
(Source: 1990 Census data)
In 1980 there was 4.1% unemployed persons in the urban areas for both sexes. This increased to 16.9% in 1990. Unemployment severely affects women who earn less than men and support large households, as seen in the table above. The following table shows the changes in employment for men and women between 1980-90.
Unemployment, urban citizen population 10 years,
by gender, 1980-1990
|
Category |
1980 |
1990 |
||
|
Male |
Female |
Male |
Female |
|
|
Total population |
143,532 |
97.098 |
220,277 |
166,826 |
|
Labour force |
91,290 |
21,175 |
158,800 |
57,749 |
|
Unemployed/labour force |
8.9 |
8.6 |
28.6 |
34.3 |
|
Unemployed population |
5.6 |
1.9 |
20.6 |
11.9 |
In the urban areas, there are a number of child care facilities, ranging from child-minding to preschool. These are governed by the Child Welfare Act for licensing. Cost for these are K70-100 per fortnight which represents a large portion of the lower levels of the wage scale. A keyboard operator will typically earn K200/fortnight. Most women rely on family and fiends to provide child care as costs are prohibitive. There is a need for government to provide subsidized child care at affordable rates according to salary level.
Housing is an emerging development problem in Papua New Guinea.... In the urban society housing has become a critical issue that requires urgent attention particularly because of lack of proper housing to suit the needs of families, urban single workers, and female-headed households. The increase in labour force and female participation particularly in the urban centers is not being addressed by urban planning authorities.
Existing data available from the 1990 census is not disaggregated by gender and is focused on the ownership of homes and types of housing in existence in the urban centers. Although there is an increase in home ownership, the great majority of Papua New Guineans, about 66% in urban areas, live in low cost housing, in domestic workers quarters and the urban settlements. The number of domestic quarters has doubled from 1980 to 1990. This reflects the growing demands of the working population for domestic workers in urban centers and an increase in urban migration to major centers.
There is no effective response to the accommodation demands of a fast-growing labour force although the real estate industry is emerging strongly in the industrial centers of Papua New Guinea.... Housing for young women and female workers consists primarily of hostel accommodation which is very limited. The few hostels in existence are run by government, non-government organizations and churches. The conditions of government run hostels are very poor, unhygienic and insecure. most hostels are based in the nation’s capital of Port Moresby, with one based in Lae and one in Goroka. Women’s hostels established by Papa new Guinea non-government organizations are managed by the Young Women’s Christian Association, Country Women’s Association, Catholic Church and the Girl Guides of PNG. However there is a great need for their expansion to other centers.
The 1990 census revealed an increase in marriage breakdown. In urban centers the percentage of separation or divorce was 1.7% for females and 1.3% for males. This implies that the incidence of single parent female-headed households is increasing and so will the demand for appropriate accommodation. This matter will need to be monitored closely by housing authorities and social service providers. Current policy and housing schemes are not insensitive to special categories of the population, particularly female-headed households.
Existing government housing policy is targeted at the urban population involved in the productive formal sector. The government is no longer building houses to rent but is encouraging home ownership schemes due to the huge maintenance costs that are incurred by government. All houses owned by the government have been sold to the public servants living in them. However, there are no new developments for new recruitments of public sector employees. The government has directed its agencies to set up national home ownership schemes for its employees.... It is difficult to establish how many Papua New Guinean women have access to services and are utilizing such home ownership schemes. Information on existing schemes is not always made available or accessible to women.
There are may other issues that need to be addressed, such as accommodation for women and girls attending tertiary education institutions. The design of dormitories and female hostels needs to be carefully reviewed to ensure that they are secured and comfortable....
...More than 90% of all land falls under customary ownership system, which defines people’s rights to benefit from the land. The clan decides who can use the land and for what purposes.... practically none of the land is surveyed, registered or formally demarcated. In the customary land areas, the individual’s rights to land a re ill-defined and, with rising demographic pressures, land disputes have become more common.
Customary land cannot be transferred or mortgaged to non-automatic citizens, effectively disqualifying the use of land as collateral for loans and reducing incentives to conserve land or invest in land intensive activities.
Alienated land is the term applied to land that does not fall under customary ownership and accounts for about 2%, or one million hectares, of total land, mostly in urban areas....
Two-thirds of PNG women belong to families in which women own land, while the remaining minority do not own land. There are two types of land ownership: individually owned, particularly in urban areas, and tribally owned in rural areas. Within the tribes, land is divided along patrilineal or matrilineal lines. It is assumed that 40% of women belong to a family whose land is registered(i.e. property of family) and 60% have claims on customary land.
Today’s modern economic system which encourages buying and selling of land may affect existing social systems, create landlessness and eventually lead to poverty and immense social upheaval. Where matrilineal clan lineage exists, women are slowly being overlooked in negotiations for large mining and agricultural estate projects by government. Women are being replaced by their brothers and sons during such negotiations and therefore losing their control over the use of their land, leading to exploitation of natural resources such as timber.
Devilment of land has brought on new pressures as well as opportunity for women and their families. It is booming a common sight these days to see men and families suffer from the negative effects of such developments, which are not gender-responsive to the needs of women and their communities. Many large agricultural estates have reported incidents of family breakdown in marriages where housing is not provided for whole families; there is a rise in prostitution and sexually transmitted diseases; families have a poor nutritional status; shortage of land to do gardening and dependence on tinned imported foodstuffs; and poor water supply, sanitation and environmental problems.
Women as the main users and landowners have a major role to play in protecting a sustainable environment. Most environmental groups are involved in literacy training suing environmental education materials and landowner awareness projects. In view of the emergence of non-government organizations such as the Melanesian Environmental Foundation and the National Alliance of Non-Government Organizations, much pressure has been exerted on government and developers to be more responsible in the use of the environment. Another initiative such as the Tropical Action Plan has been actively promoting landowner awareness and advocating the rights of landowners. As far as women’s non-government organizations are concerned the East Sepik Council of Women is actively involved in such activities and has a project which could become a model for others.
For further information, please contact the South-East
Asia and the Pacific Multidisciplinary
Advisory Team (SEAPAT) at Tel: +63.2.815.2354
or Fax: +63.2.812.6143
E-mail:
seapat@ilo.org