|
As expected, western European countries have the highest scores, making
up entirely the cluster of Pacesetters. Top performers are Luxembourg,
Norway, Sweden, Finland and Denmark. There are no Pacesetters in any other
region. Eastern Europe and the Americas are the regions having the best
performing industrializing or transitional economies: Argentina, Barbados,
Chile, Czech Republic, Estonia, Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania and Slovakia.
These countries are classified as Pragmatists. As such, by definition,
they have relatively weak legislation related to work security, or on
mechanisms to ensure the application of the laws, but still achieve good
results in the outcome measures.
By contrast, however, over two thirds of the countries in our list have
unsatisfactory levels of work security. The latter are classified as Conventionals
or Much-to-be-Done, in almost equal numbers. These two clusters contain
countries from all regions (except Western Europe) and all countries from
Africa and Middle East (except Israel, which is a Pragmatist) as well
as from Asia (except Asian OECD countries, which are also Pragmatists).
The Conventionals could be considered as "average" performers
in that they have satisfactory institutional or legislative mechanisms
and/or satisfactory mechanisms for implementing those norms, but nonetheless
perform rather poorly on the outcome measures. Probably for historical
reasons the majority of African and Latin American countries come under
this label.
Finally, the most critical cases are in the category of Much-to-be-Done,
which takes in the most deprived countries from the African continent,
Asia and Eastern Europe. The countries of Eastern Europe have a history
of strong legislation on the various aspects of work security, including
nearly 100% trade union membership until the fall of Communism. Some of
the other countries, particularly those in Asia, have more recently upgraded
what were basic factory acts carried over from colonial periods to include
other laws on work security. Yet the results show that, while laws and
mechanisms may exist, alone they are insufficient to protect workers
health.
|